12/13/2023 0 Comments Mtg cardsmith set maker![]() The site revamp is coming, but I don't yet have a date or more information than that. If they genuinely expect us to want to participate in challenges, then they need to give us apt tools and not, in all honesty, a terrible, limited and aged card creation program. ![]() The forms are certainly great, but crippled by the card engine itself. Keep in mind that barely anything was added since 2017, and that nearly all of these features are fixed on other sites and programs. A featured card system that often showcases lackluster or terrible designs, most of the time showing the MTGCardsmith team as people who don't know balance.Inability to make split cards, sagas, adventure cards without using ascii's.Inability to create cards that transform without creating two separate cards.Numerous missing frames, including the future sight frame, old-school frame, devoid frame, unstable land frame, flip frame, conspiracy frames, miracle frames, eta.Inability to put snow mana or colorless mana symbols above 9 into the mana cost.Only 2 card sizes, and a system that doesn't automatically set card sizes like what both MSE and MTGDesign do.Having to pay to remove the card capacity limit.In fact, I'll list a long list of things that make the card engine itself abysmal, since there are so many and the mtgcardsmith team needs to step it up: And MTGCardsmith is sluggish at best in updating the main site. Every other site looks better because of it. The issue is the card text itself - when you only have two options for text size, and it clips outside of the card most of the time, that isn't a sign of a good site. I get where you're coming from, but it would be foolish to try and gatekeep or force out what might prove to be a handy tool for some of the creators here. I personally use MSE to document the vast majority of my ideas, and then skim off a small number of them to put up on CS for contests and stuff. ![]() It isn't as though the site's got a forum or whatever for people to vanish into, and the Cardsmith forums can first and foremost be argued to be about the community ideal of creating custom MTG cards, not forcing people to conform into always using the same editors and methods.įor example, MSE is something that people recommend to others here every now and again. While some contests do ask that entries are specifically made using CS, that's about as far as medium bias tends to be worth bringing, I think. I'm sure I'll stick with my MSE for technicalities and general storage and CS for custom frames and community-sharing, but it's nice to know it I'm with RandomFandom on this one. It seems alright and the cards made with it are visually crisp, though it looks like it's got its limitations.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |